I Don’t Belong Here w/ Samantha Benigno

Welcome, Welcome, Welcome! This is The I Don't Belong Here audio channel, where the goal is to use psychology & behavioral analysis to delve deeply into popular true crime cases. Here we use the testimony of witnesses, interrogation videos, legal documents, etc., and all that we have access to, to get closer to the Truth.

My name is Samantha Benigno, I am a behavioral scientist, a master’s level psychologist, a 6th year PhD candidate in Clinical Psychology, and a career psychotherapist with 25 years of clinical experience. Join me, as I dive deep into the evidence to develop a comprehensive understanding of the players, and with your help, seek to expose the whole truth, and nothing but the truth!

Please note the opinions that lie within are just that, my opinions, and should not be confused with a complete clinical or forensic analyses. 

If you enjoy this show and for a more in depth analysis check out my YouTube channel @IDBHTrueCrime.

Episodes

Aug 16, 2026

18 min

Friday August 14th Judge Paul Wong rules over a motion to determine whether a new trial should be granted in the Konig case. Find out what happens and whether or not we will really be doing this again? Thanks to  @JusticeIsAProcess  for their footage in this case!!! 

Aug 16, 2026

18 min

May 21, 2026

1 hr 41 min

In this final episode you will hear my informed opinion of what happened to Boston Police Officer John O'Keefe and why I believe it.
To see a video version of what I believe happened to John O'Keefe.
To see a slightly different video version of the series you can check find it here. 
If you are interested in this topic you will want to check out the prologue series called The End of Innocence where we explore outstanding questions and important topics related to the case. 
Join me Samantha Benigno, MA, MS, CASAC, RYT, behavioral scientist and MA psychologist/counselor as I breakdown the fall out from the Karen Read murder case and continue to seek to find justice for Boston police officer John O’Keefe!
A Huge Thank you To All of the Following Contributions
Melanie Little w/ Garrett Wing
https://www.youtube.com/live/5aPZnjQlJG8?si=zCSo07DI6sNx1Dhc
@TruthRevealedbySD [Brian Higgins Video 2]
https://youtu.be/LIx0_TMwsHo?si=-VxKvIPs105rqS4W Waterfall Video Restored https://youtu.be/3KTDxC4DrKs?si=3yA1g1WgbWZ8SSq8
You can also find me, and a different version of this show, at my YouTube Channel @IDBHTrueCrime.

May 21, 2026

1 hr 41 min

Apr 30, 2026

1 hr 33 min

In this series finale Part 1 I review my current theory of the case, and will explain in great detail, exactly why and how I came to believe it.
Fight Research Link https://youtu.be/YMgxjy5KvS0
Join me Samantha Benigno, MA, MS, CASAC, RYT, behavioral scientist and MA psychologist/counselor as I breakdown the fall out from the Karen Read murder case and continue to seek to find justice for Boston police officer John O’Keefe!
A Huge Thank you To All of the Following Contributions
Melanie Little w/ Garrett Wing
https://www.youtube.com/live/5aPZnjQlJG8?si=zCSo07DI6sNx1Dhc
@TruthRevealedbySD [Brian Higgins Video 2]
https://youtu.be/LIx0_TMwsHo?si=-VxKvIPs105rqS4W Waterfall Video Restored https://youtu.be/3KTDxC4DrKs?si=3yA1g1WgbWZ8SSq8
You can also find me, and a different version of this show, at my YouTube Channel @IDBHTrueCrime.

Apr 30, 2026

1 hr 33 min

Apr 25, 2026

1 hr 18 min

While some of the McCAlbert's have elected to sue Karen Read and Aidan Kearney for conspiracy and defamation, for allegedly brainwashing all of us into believing that Karen Read is innocent and they are guilty of John O'Keefe's death. The real problem the McCalbert's have, however, those who allege to feel victimized by Karen & Aidan's mastermind, is that all of the folks who were in the house at 34 Fairview Rd on the night of Jan 29, 2022, have testified at some point across two criminal trials. This means that their words and statements about what happened and did not happen to John O'Keefe are forever etched into history. That's where we come in. In this video series we will discuss the period of time BEFORE John & Karen pull up to the house at 34 Fairview Road. A time when these" innocent" people should have absolutely no problem recounting what they were doing, yet absolutely can't.
Please be advised, the opinions that you are about to hear, are just that, they are MY OPINIONS, and should not be confused with a proper clinical or forensic analysis, or statements of fact. This video is meant to be for entertainment purposes only. "Lies" By CGLM (Opening Song) https://music.apple.com/us/album/lies/1889044604?i=1889044605
If you like this podcast there are many more videos much like it on YouTube @IDBHTrueCrime.

Apr 25, 2026

1 hr 18 min

Apr 23, 2026

3 hr 8 min

Join me, Samantha Benigno, MA, MS, CASAC, behavioral scientist, psychologist and psychotherapist, Attorney Loophole Lawyer, and our special guest Blogger, Aidan "Turtle Boy" Kearney to discuss the new lawsuit Jennifer McCabe, Brian Albert, Colin Albert, and Brian Higgins have brought against him and Karen Read. 

Apr 23, 2026

3 hr 8 min

Apr 23, 2026

1 hr 20 min

As you know we have been closely examining the time just before John O'Keefe & Karen Read pull up in front of 34 Fairview Rd on that fateful night of 1/29/22. In this episode we explore a new and evolving theory, based on their own words and statements, of what could of happened.
Please be advised, the opinions that you are about to hear, are just that, they are MY OPINIONS, and should not be confused with a proper clinical or forensic analysis, or statements of fact. This video is meant to be for entertainment purposes only. 
If you like what you hear here, you can find hundreds of videos on my YouTube Channel @IDBHTrueCrime. 
 

Apr 23, 2026

1 hr 20 min

Apr 23, 2026

54 min

As of this week some of the McCAlbert's have elected to sue Karen Read and Aidan Kearney for conspiracy and defamation, for brainwashing all of us into believing that Karen is innocent, and they are guilty of John O'Keefe's death. The real problem for the McCalbert's, however,  who allege to feel victimized by Karen & Aidan's mastermind, is no matter what they try to say, or do from now on,  their words and statements under oath, across two criminal trials, remain from now until eternity. 
In this episode we explore the actual claims the house defendants are asserting, the science of those claims, and why some in Canton and those close to the O'Keefe family may not want to believe their eyes and ears. 
Join me Samantha Benigno, MA, MS, CASAC, RYT, behavioral scientist and MA psychologist/counselor as I breakdown the fall out from the Karen Read murder case and continue to seek to find justice for Boston police officer John O’Keefe! 
Please be advised, the opinions that you are about to hear, are just that, they are MY OPINIONS, and should not be confused with a proper clinical or forensic analysis, or statements of fact. This video is meant to be for entertainment purposes only. 
As promised here are the Caitlin Albert analyses videos
https://youtu.be/fQfuGgtbppg
https://youtu.be/8g5H9Y7MAng
If you like what you hear here, you can find hundreds of videos on my YouTube Channel @IDBHTrueCrime. 
 

Apr 23, 2026

54 min

Apr 19, 2026

33 min

A few days ago we learned that Jennifer McCabe, Colin Albert, Brian Albert, & Brian Higgins, "witnesses" who testified in the Karen Read criminal trials have elected to sue Karen Read & Aidan Kearney claiming they knowingly obfuscated justice by scheming a conspiracy to  brainwash all of us into believing John O'Keefe was killed by one of them, and not Karen Read. Listen to my first, off the cuff, response to this news exclusively available here, on the podcast. 

Apr 19, 2026

33 min

Apr 18, 2026

50 min

As of this week some of the McCAlbert's have elected to sue Karen Read and Aidan Kearney for conspiracy and defamation, for brainwashing all of us into believing that Karen is innocent, and they (Higgins, Brian Albert, Colin Albert, and JEN McCabe??????) are guilty of John O'Keefe's death. While they may have duped some of their Canton pals (and a handful of half-wit's who believe science to be over-rated), back here in reality, where the rest of us live, the physics continues to attest to Karen's innocence. The real problem for the McCalbert's, however, who allege to feel victimized by Karen & Aidan's mastermind, is no matter what they try to say, or do from now on,  their words and statements under oath, across two criminal trials, remain from now until eternity. 
 
In this video series we will discuss the period of time BEFORE John & Karen pull up to the house at 34 Fairview Road. A time when these innocent people should have absolutely no problem recounting to us what they were doing for the 20-35 minutes BEFORE John & Karen arrive from the Waterfall. 
 
A special shout out to  @TheTrialChannel_    for their footage,  and their hard work on this case. They make this video  possible! You can check out their new channel  @TTCFiles   for even more relevant ❤️! Please check them out ! 
 
Join me Samantha Benigno, MA, MS, CASAC, RYT, behavioral scientist and MA psychologist/counselor as I breakdown the fall out from the Karen Read murder case and continue to seek to find justice for Boston police officer John O’Keefe! 
Please be advised, the opinions that you are about to hear, are just that, they are MY OPINIONS, and should not be confused with a proper clinical or forensic analysis, or statements of fact. This video is meant to be for entertainment purposes only. 
As promised here are the Caitlin Albert analyses videos
https://youtu.be/fQfuGgtbppg
https://youtu.be/8g5H9Y7MAng
If you enjoy this podcast you can find countless more videos on my YouTube Channel @IDBHTrueCrime
 

Apr 18, 2026

50 min

Apr 16, 2026

35 min

Brian & Lynette Hooker are American sailors from Michigan, known for their "The Sailing Hookers" social media pages, where they had been documenting their sailing adventures. In 2020 the couple sold everything to live their dream of an "authentic" sailing life. Brian claims that on the night of April 4, while traveling from Hope Town to Elbow Cay in rough conditions, Lynette fell overboard with the boat keys, stalling the engine. He reported being unable to find her, paddling to shore, and alerting authorities early the next morning. The problem is those closest to Lynette do not by this story and neither do police. As it turns out when you listen closely to Mr. Hooker's statement, there are VERY SERIOUS PROBLEMS ALREADY!  Lynette's family, including her daughter, and her Mother, have expressed skepticism regarding the account, citing the couple's volatile relationship history and that Lynette was an experienced sailor. In this video we explore these explains and discuss what really happened to Lynette.
Featured in this video with much gratitude and respect are the following sites...
@dropdeadserious
https://youtu.be/el7hVYiIy-U?si=ZQ0KbNJnrtJTFZhR
@unmaskedTrueCrime
https://youtu.be/U5ylvmq8ysw?si=lZDAVjosbsZSUYbl
@thesailinghookers
https://youtu.be/lsUA9Xqr9PY?si=mtWFhIjiNNSfnyr2
@today
https://youtu.be/QA2mUi524UA?si=yJvpCH16nnm9BgtR
@sailingcameo
https://youtu.be/eDEgn6Qhc1o?si=2bitSI9ZczWbKdVG
If you enjoy this podcast you can check out my YouTube Channel @IDBHTrueCrime. 
Please be advised that the opinions contained within and expressed in this video are just that, my OPINIONS and do not represent a proper psychological or forensic analysis. 

Apr 16, 2026

35 min

Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.

Podcast Powered By Podbean

Version: 20241125